What distinction does the Griz draw between a vow concerning Yitzchak’s descendants and one concerning Rivkah’s?
According to the Griz’s novel ruling cited here, a vow prohibiting benefit from Yitzchak’s descendants does not include Esav’s descendants, whereas the corresponding vow concerning Rivkah’s descendants does. The basis is that Esav remains part of Rivkah’s offspring while being excluded from the relevant lineage of Yitzchak. The text also reports that the Griz left this explanation out of his book out of respect for Rashi’s statement that he did not know what the verse teaches.
A practical halachic question: the final ruling is for your rabbi.
Quote from the source«איני יודע מה מלמדנו»
- Author
- הגרי"ז מבריסק
- Source
- נעימות הפרשה — נעימות הפרשה — Toldos 5787, p. 16
- Parsha
- Toldot