Why did Rav Elyashiv rebuke parents who gave their child to childless relatives and concealed his parentage?
In the story, parents gave their eleventh child to the mother's sister and her husband, considering it a great kindness, but concealed the child's parentage. When they consulted Rav Elyashiv twenty years later, he rebuked them for depriving the child of the opportunity to honor his biological parents. Kindness to another family does not justify neglecting obligations toward the child.
This answer was given to a specific person, not as a general rule.
Quote from the source«Who gave you the right to do such a thing!»
- Author
- ר' אלישב זצ"ל
- Source
- Taking the Parshiyos With Us — Taking the Parshiyos With Us — Vayeira 5787, p. 38
- Parsha
- Vayera