May someone take another person’s property without permission if they intend to return it improved?
Rabbi Meir HaLevi explains that a Jew may not steal even as a joke or with the intention of returning the property improved; assistance should be arranged with the owner in another way. The text explains Iyov’s practice of taking an orphan’s neglected field, cultivating it, and returning it by noting that Iyov was not Jewish. According to this explanation, for a non-Jew such an act that ultimately benefits the owner does not constitute prohibited theft.
A practical halachic question: the final ruling is for your rabbi.
Quote from the source««Не кради» – нельзя украсть даже ради шутки, чтобы потом вернуть.»
- Author
- Рабби Меир а-Леви
- Source
- Fond Nasledia — offline 141 shavuot 2019, p. 5