Why does Ramban object to explaining Moshe's sin as striking instead of speaking?
Ramban points out that the command to take the staff could imply using it to strike, as in other cases described in the Torah. Moreover, producing water through speech is no greater a miracle for the rock than producing it through a blow. In his view, Rashi's explanation therefore does not account for the narrative's literal meaning or the severity of the accusation.
The source brings differing opinions.
Quote from the source«И чудо не больше в речении, чем в ударе, поскольку всё [это] одинаково для скалы.»
- Author
- Рамбан
- Source
- Fond Nasledia — offline 145 HUKAT E Israel 2019, p. 8