Why did the story of Shabtai Tzvi's miracle fail to convince the sages that he was Mashiach?
In the story, Shabtai Tzvi tore a piece of wool and declared that a wicked man would die; his visitors later learned that the man had died that day. The sages nevertheless pointed out that the prophecy describes Mashiach striking the wicked with the breath of his lips, without additional physical actions. The lesson is that an extraordinary event is insufficient: it must match the signs specified in the prophecy.
This answer was given to a specific person, not as a general rule.
Quote from the source«Ну! Чем не чудо?»
- Author
- рав Нахум Шатхин
- Source
- Fond Nasledia — offline 146 BALAK E Israel 2019, p. 17
- Parsha
- Balak