How is Shmuel's appearance to Shaul explained if consulting the medium was forbidden?
Rabbi Nachum Shatkhin clarifies that it was Shaul, not David, who consulted the medium, and that doing so was forbidden. He cites commentators who explain that the session began in impurity, but subsequent events occurred by God's will to help Shaul atone for his sins. Shmuel's words that Shaul and his sons would be with him are interpreted as an offer to go into battle and, through dying there, merit being with the righteous in Paradise; Shaul accepted that choice.
This answer was given to a specific person, not as a general rule.
Quote from the source«И царь Шауль делает свой выбор.»
- Author
- рав Нахум Шатхин
- Source
- Fond Nasledia — offline 150 DVARIM 2019, p. 16
- Parsha
- Devarim