What is the shamash for, and when can it be omitted?
Using the light of a Hanukkah candle, for example for writing, is forbidden, so an additional light source is needed. The explanation given requires an extra candle even when no use of the light is intended, to make it clear that the Hanukkah candles were lit for the mitzvah. If another light source is present, such as a lamp or a fire, the extra candle is unnecessary. However, someone accustomed to using candlelight specifically must light one even when a fire is present.
A practical halachic question: the final ruling is for your rabbi.
Quote from the source«Это нужно сделать, даже если человек не собирается пользоваться светом вообще,»
- Author
- рав Ицхак Зильбер
- Source
- Fond Nasledia — offline 169 miketz 2019, p. 15
- Parsha
- Miketz