Why were the Egyptians punished if the enslavement of the Jews had been decreed by God?
In the article's presentation of Rambam, the general decree did not remove each Egyptian's freedom of choice or responsibility for treating the Jews cruelly. Raavad objects and offers three explanations: God used people who were already wicked and then punished them as they deserved; Pharaoh deserved a separate punishment for defying the Creator; and the Egyptians exceeded the measure of enslavement through cruel abuse and the killing of children. Ramban also shares the last explanation. The article's author notes that questions remain about the explanation based on exceeding the prescribed measure.
The source brings differing opinions.
Quote from the source«Но каждый египтянин был совершенно свободен в своём выборе и мог бы не издеваться над евреем.»
- Author
- Рамбам; Раавад; Рамбан; Рав Яков Доктор
- Source
- Fond Nasledia — offline 174 bo 2020, p. 8
- Parsha
- Bo