How does the article explain the disagreement about the Shekhinah in exile and the significance of commandments outside Israel?
The article presents Ramban’s position as follows: the full realization of the commandments is tied to the Land of Israel, while observance in exile prepares for the return. It contrasts this with Rav Ezra bar-Shlomo of Gerona’s view that the Shekhinah accompanies the Jews in exile and that its end should not be artificially hastened. The passage presents a disagreement rather than a single practical ruling.
The source brings differing opinions.
Quote from the source«Мы как бы тренируемся в исполнении мицвот, но их истинное исполнение возможно только в Израиле.»
- Author
- Рамбан; рав Эзра бар-Шломо из Героны
- Source
- Fond Nasledia — offline 200 Ekev 2020, p. 16
- Parsha
- Eikev