What rebuke was contained in Yosef’s question, “Is my father still alive?”
Beit HaLevi explains that Yosef confronted his brothers with a contradiction in their own conduct. Yehuda argued that their father could not survive losing Binyamin, although the brothers had already inflicted a similar blow by selling Yosef. The question did not seek new information; it exposed the weakness of their justifications. This confrontation with the truth of one’s own actions is described as the strongest rebuke.
Quote from the source«Иначе говоря: ты не можешь нанести отцу такой удар?»
- Author
- Бейт а-леви
- Source
- Fond Nasledia — offline 220 vaigash 2020, p. 6