Why did Rabban Gamliel reject the crescent people thought they saw as evidence of a new month?
Rabban Gamliel relied on a tradition received from his ancestors about when the new moon could appear and concluded that people had mistaken a cloud for a crescent. He therefore rejected the testimony. He then delivered a lengthy eulogy so that people would understand that the new month had not been declared, since eulogies are not delivered on Rosh Chodesh. The story shows that eyewitness impressions were assessed in light of transmitted knowledge.
Quote from the source«Поэтому я не принимаю свидетелей — облачко им показалось луной».»
- Author
- Рабан Гамлиэль
- Source
- Fond Nasledia — offline 353 REE 2023, p. 7