Can the story of Pinchas be understood as general permission for religious violence?
Rav Yisrael Zelman cites Talmudic restrictions: judges may not direct a zealot to carry out such an act, and acting outside the prescribed limits makes the act murder. According to the Jerusalem Talmud as he quotes it, even Pinchas’s deed was contrary to the sages’ wishes, and only direct divine intervention prevented his excommunication. The account therefore provides no general permission for violence in the name of faith.
Quote from the source«Это все — с юридической стороны,»
- Author
- РАВ ИСРАЕЛЬ ЗЕЛЬМАН
- Source
- Fond Nasledia — offline 37 pinchas 2017, p. 19
- Parsha
- Pinchas