Why are Jews relatively few if Abraham was promised descendants as numerous as the stars and sand?
Rav Menachem Epel presents several interpretations: one applies the promise about the dust of the earth to all Abraham’s descendants, including those of Ishmael, Esau, and Keturah’s children, while the comparison to stars concerns Jacob’s descendants. Some commentators understand the language as an exaggeration, whereas Midrash Sifrei insists on a literal reading. Other interpretations place fulfillment after Mashiach’s arrival; the author suggests that complete numerical fulfillment may also occur then. Rabbi Shimshon Raphael Hirsch considers counting all generations together but prefers to emphasize the many descendants of one forefather forming a single family. The Maggid of Dubno and Rabbi Mordechai Yosef of Izhbitza explain innumerability through the significance of each Jew who fulfills the Creator’s will: a simple headcount cannot express their true value.
The source brings differing opinions.
This answer was given to a specific person, not as a general rule.
Quote from the source«Народ Израиля — это самая большая семья на земле.»
- Author
- рав Менахем Эпель
- Source
- Fond Nasledia — offline 434 Vayakel 2025, p. 16
- Parsha
- Vayakhel