Why does Rashi treat the first explanation as primary even though the second resolves several difficulties?
The second explanation ties the change to the completion of forty years, leaving it difficult to explain why the verse emphasizes arriving “at this place.” It also leaves unclear why those words separate the earlier miracles from the war with Sihon and Og. The first explanation connects the warning specifically with the transition to settled life in the land and is therefore closer to the verse’s plain meaning.
Quote from the source«ולכן מביא רש"י פי' זה רק כפי' השני, והראשון הוא העיקרי והקרוב יותר לפשש"מ.»
- Author
- הרבי
- Source
- Hagahos HaRebbe — 5727-12 (2) ש"פ תבוא תשכ"ה ותשכ"ז, p. 38