Should I tell someone they overpaid if the money cannot be recovered?
If the transaction is complete, compensation cannot legally be demanded, and disclosure will serve no useful purpose, telling the buyer about the deception is forbidden even if they ask. However, if they plan to make further purchases from the same seller, they must be warned to prevent future losses. Doubts about the transaction's legality should be discussed with an expert in Torah law.
A practical halachic question: the final ruling is for your rabbi.
Quote from the source«При всех сомнениях, касающихся законности сделки, связанной с мошенничеством, следует посоветоваться со знатоком Торы.»
- Author
- РАВ ЗЕЛИГ ПЛИСКИН
- Source
- Fond Nasledia — offline 84 Behukatay E.Israel 2018, p. 19