How did bringing water from the rock test the people?
According to Rabbi Y. Heller, water flowing in response to Moshe's words would have demonstrated the people's readiness to obey God willingly. The need for a blow would have indicated that they could obey only under pressure. Moshe feared that the people's spiritual condition would make speech alone insufficient and that a failure to produce water would desecrate God's Name, so he struck the rock.
Quote from the source«И поэтому он ударил!»
- Author
- р. Й. Геллер
- Source
- Fond Nasledia — offline 90 hukat 2018, p. 14