Should we help someone put on tefillin even if we know he will have no intention to fulfill the mitzvah?
Yes, even in that case one must endeavor to have him put on tefillin. The text cites the Magen Avraham’s conclusion, adopted as a halachic ruling by the Alter Rebbe, that the principle that mitzvot do not require intention is applied where it leads to a stricter requirement. This conclusion, stated regarding the verbal mitzvah of counting the Omer, applies all the more to tefillin, a mitzvah performed through action.
A practical halachic question: the final ruling is for your rabbi.
Quote from the source«ועפי"ז, אפילו באם הייתה מציאות שידעו ברור שגם הכוונה כללית לעשיית מצוה לא יתכוון, מחוייבים להשתדל שיניח תפלין.»
- Author
- כ"ק אדמו"ר מלך המשיח שליט"א
- Source
- Hagahos HaRebbe — 5728-01 ש"פ בראשית תשכ"ח-6
- Parsha
- Bereishit