When should a victim decline repayment offered by a repentant thief?
When someone who made a living by theft voluntarily repents and offers payment for stolen items no longer in their possession, the Sages instituted that the victim forgive the debt and decline payment to encourage repentance. This applies even to a wealthy thief, but not to stolen real estate. If the victim owes money to others, they should accept payment to meet those obligations. Payment may also be accepted when the thief insists on paying to obtain complete atonement.
A practical halachic question: the final ruling is for your rabbi.
Quote from the source«Yet, this doesn’t apply to stolen real estate.»
- Author
- Rabbi Chaim Hillel Raskin
- Source
- The Weekly Farbrengen — 532 - Remembering Him (I), p. 2