How is a transgression committed under coercion judged?
When the law requires preserving life through a transgression, the text condemns refusing to transgress and consequently dying. When the law requires refusal even at the cost of life, fulfilling that requirement sanctifies God's Name, while transgressing desecrates it. Nevertheless, a Jewish court does not punish that coerced transgression because it was not voluntary. The text separately condemns someone who could escape the coercive ruler's authority but fails to do so.
A practical halachic question: the final ruling is for your rabbi.
Quote from the source«И если это было в присутствии десяти евреев – то освятил Имя публично («кидуш а-Шем бэ рабим»),»
- Author
- Редакция «Хитас»
- Source
- Chitas — Хитас Трума Четверг 5786, p. 25
- Parsha
- Terumah