Was the command to set aside a portion of the spoils of Midian limited to that occasion, or did it also apply to future generations?
The text presents Rambam’s view that this was a one-time command, which he therefore excludes from the count of commandments, alongside the opposing position of Baal Halakhot Gedolot. Noda BiYehuda distinguishes between the two portions: the levy from the community’s half was a one-time requirement, while the one-five-hundredth levy from the warriors’ share applies to future generations as well. On this explanation, the Talmud’s statement that the Midian offering does not apply to future generations refers to the community’s portion.
The source brings differing opinions.
Quote from the source«תרומת מדין אינה נוהגת לדורות»
- Author
- נודע ביהודה
- Source
- Hagahos HaRebbe — 5732-10 (2) ש"פ מטו"מ תשל"ב-1