Why is it difficult to explain that the dove brought the leaf from Gan Eden?
The guarding of Gan Eden is understood to bar more than Adam alone: the flaming, turning sword would also frighten the dove. Animals too ate from the Tree of Knowledge and became subject to death, so the expulsion applied to them as well. Ramban’s suggestion that the gates opened after the waters receded also does not fit the verse’s direct wording, which presents the leaf itself as the basis for Noach’s knowledge.
The source brings differing opinions.
Quote from the source«הרי גם עליהם חל הגירוש מג"ע.»
- Author
- Ребе
- Source
- Hagahos HaRebbe — 5734-02 ש"פ נח תשל"ד-2, p. 39
- Parsha
- Noach