Why does the explanation that the dove brought its leaf from Gan Eden or the Land of Israel not fit the plain meaning of the account?
The Midrash offers both explanations, but the discourse explains why they do not resolve the plain meaning of the verses. The entrance to Gan Eden was guarded, and a leaf from a place untouched by the Flood would not tell Noach that the waters elsewhere had subsided. Even if water entered the Land of Israel from neighboring lands, it could have receded there earlier than elsewhere.
The source brings differing opinions.
Quote from the source«ומה ראה מזה שהביאה עלה זית מג"ע, הרי שם לא הי' המבול מעיקרא?»
- Author
- הרבי
- Source
- Hagahos HaRebbe — 5734-02 ש"פ נח תשל"ד-2, p. 14
- Parsha
- Noach