Why are two witnesses required for a sotah's seclusion but only one for adultery?
The Mishnah considers using an a fortiori argument to require the same number of witnesses in both cases, but rejects this on scriptural grounds. The words “ועד אין בה” provide the basis for accepting one witness to adultery. The requirement of two witnesses for the earlier testimony about seclusion is derived by linking the word “דבר” to the verse concerning two witnesses.
A practical halachic question: the final ruling is for your rabbi.
Quote from the source«עַ ל ּפִ י ׁשְ נַ יִ ם עֵ ִדים יָ קּום ָּדבָ ר»
- Author
- Редакция «Хитас»
- Source
- Chitas — Хитас Тецаве Четверг 5786, p. 35
- Parsha
- Tetzaveh