How does Re’em explain why Rashi derives a rule about the birth of a girl from Dinah’s story, although she was originally male?
Re’em explains that since Dinah was ultimately female and the verse associates her with her father, it can teach Rashi’s stated rule that when the man emits seed first, a girl is born, despite her original state. The Rebbe, however, finds this explanation highly problematic: how can a general rule be established from a case in which it did not actually operate? The text provides no answer to this objection.
The source brings differing opinions.
Quote from the source«איש מזריע תחלה יולדת נקבה»
- Author
- רא״ם
- Source
- Hagahos HaRebbe — 5748-04 (1) ש"פ ויגש ה' טבת תשמ"ח-2, p. 2
- Parsha
- Vayigash