Why is there a disagreement about whether a completely righteous person or a penitent is greater?
According to the Maharsha's explanation quoted here, the penitent in this dispute considered a sin but did not commit it. One view ranks him higher for overcoming a trial that the completely righteous person never faced; the other favors someone who did not sin even in thought. The article suggests connecting this disagreement to Avraham and Yitzchak's mutual esteem: each regarded the other's spiritual standing as greater.
The source brings differing opinions.
Quote from the source«והמ"ד השני סובר דמכל מקום צדיק גמור יותר חשוב מכיון שלא חטא כלל אף לא במחשבה ע"ש.»
- Author
- המהרש"א; Редакция «אמונת חיים»
- Source
- אמונת חיים — אמונת חיים — Toldos 5787, p. 1
- Parsha
- Toldot