Is an unresolved conceptual difficulty enough to depart from a ruling of the Rema?
In the case cited, the Chazon Ish found the Rema’s ruling in the name of Terumat HaDeshen entirely incomprehensible and concluded that it should not be followed. Rabbi Dov Lando contrasts this with Rabbi Akiva Eiger, whose words suggest that a conceptual objection alone would not justify departing from that ruling.
The source brings differing opinions.
Quote from the source«בליטא נהגו אחרת בענין זה.»
- Author
- רבי דב לנדו
- Source
- לקראת שבת - עיונים וביאורים בפרשת השבוע — 5786-לקראת_שבת_תזריע_מצורע, p. 3
- Parsha
- Tazria