If only religion unites the Jews and they are a people, why aren't Christians and Muslims considered peoples?
The premise is wrong: the Jews are a unique people because we are at once a people in the ordinary sense and a religious community. We have a common origin from Avraham, Yitzchak and Yaakov; a common, well-known territory from which we were exiled twice and to which we recently returned, re-establishing our state; a common language throughout all three thousand years; a common, single faith. By all these recognised parameters we are 'even more' a people than any other: which other people can say that all of them have remained unchanged over thousands of years? From our being a religious community follows a 'procedure' for joining the people - conversion (giyur): having undergone it by the laws of the Torah, anyone - a Mongol, a Russian, a Chinese - becomes a Jew and an adherent of Judaism. Here we differ fundamentally: a Mongol who adopts Christianity remains a Mongol, a Russian who adopts Islam remains Russian. Therefore Christians and Muslims cannot be considered separate peoples by any of the criteria that define the concept of 'a people'.
This answer was given to a specific person, not as a general rule.
Quote from the source«мы одновременно — и народ (в обычном смысле этого слова) и религиозная общность»
- Author
- Элиягу Эссас
- Source
- Love Doing Good — journal-184, p. 8