Must a borrower pay for a borrowed car and a kayak in its trunk if the car unexpectedly burns during a journey?
Under the ruling given, the borrower need not pay for the car if it was driven properly, showed no warning signs, and unexpectedly caught fire because of the engine during the journey. This falls under the exemption of meta machamat melacha: an item lost through the use for which it was borrowed. The kayak had no defect of its own and was not destroyed through its own use, so the borrower must pay its value at the time of the loss. It remains subject to a borrower's ordinary liability even for unavoidable accidents.
A practical halachic question: the final ruling is for your rabbi.
Quote from the source«השואל פטור מתשלום דמי הרכב, אבל את דמי הקיאק שנשרף עליו לשלם.»
- Author
- הרב ארז חזני
- Source
- HaDibrot — 1785018577-עלון-765-עקב-הדברות, p. 10
- Parsha
- Eikev