If Avraham observed the entire Torah before it was given, why did he wait for God’s command to circumcise himself?
Riva explains that circumcision is performed once, and Avraham wanted the greater merit of performing it as someone commanded to do so. Another explanation is that before the command, the foreskin did not yet have the relevant legal status, so removing it then would not constitute circumcision and would prevent complete fulfillment later. The article also proposes that Avraham’s voluntary observance of laws not yet commanded could not override the already binding prohibition against shedding his own blood. Only the explicit command of circumcision permitted the act. Refraining beforehand was therefore itself part of observing the entire Torah.
The source brings differing opinions.
Quote from the source«כי בנדו"ד קיום התורה הוא דוקא בביטול המילה.»
- Author
- כ"ק אדמו"ר מליובאוויטש
- Source
- Likrat Shabbat — 5787 עלוני חב״ד; לקראת שבת - תולדות, p. 13
- Parsha
- Toldot