Why does Rashi give three explanations for Yitzchak’s failing eyesight instead of attributing it to old age?
Other commentators attribute the failing eyesight to old age, but in Rashi’s explanation, God’s special blessing to Yitzchak makes such prolonged suffering from aging alone difficult to accept. Smoke from the idolatrous worship of Esav’s wives comes first because it follows the adjacent verses, although it leaves questions about how the smoke reached Yitzchak and why Rivkah was unaffected. The explanation involving the angels’ tears at the Akeidah rests on Midrash, but connects Yaakov’s receiving the blessings with the merit of the Akeidah. The third explanation—that Yaakov should receive the blessings—accounts for why Yitzchak specifically lost his sight and why this happened before the blessing. Yet it leaves the question of why God chose such prolonged suffering as the means, so each explanation supplements the others.
The source brings differing opinions.
Quote from the source«כי כל פירוש בפני עצמו אינו חד וחלק, כדלקמן.»
- Author
- כ"ק אדמו"ר מליובאוויטש
- Source
- Likrat Shabbat — 5787 עלוני חב״ד; לקראת שבת - תולדות, p. 6
- Parsha
- Toldot