Does explaining an established ruling require evidence as strong as that needed to challenge it?
The discourse distinguishes between explaining an explicit Torah ruling and challenging it: an explanation does not require equally strong evidence, because the ruling itself supports the explanation. Merely suggesting that things might be otherwise is insufficient to refute an explanation that accounts for the ruling.
Quote from the source«ווארום דער פס״ד אליין איז א ראי׳ אויף דעם.»
- Author
- כ״ק אדמו״ר שליט״א
- Source
- מאמרים — 02 שיחת ש''פ חיי שרה, מבה''ח כסלו, p. 17
- Parsha
- Chayei Sarah