How can an extra safeguard help even when a person fails to keep it?
In the Chida's explanation, a safeguard creates distance between a person and the prohibition itself. Failing to maintain the safeguard therefore does not necessarily mean committing the underlying transgression. The text illustrates this with a gust of wind: one man's hat blew away but his kippah remained, while a man without a hat lost his kippah as well.
Quote from the source«עדיין לא פגע באיסור עצמו»
- Author
- החיד"א
- Source
- Beer HaParsha — באר הפרשה - כי תצא תשפ''ו A4, p. 12
- Parsha
- Ki Teitzei