Can visible deeds explain why someone continues to live despite their sins?
Rambam writes that a person whose sins outweigh their merits dies immediately, while Raavad objects that the decree means a shortened lifespan rather than immediate death. Kesef Mishneh explains Rambam’s position by emphasizing that only God knows the weight of merits and sins. They are assessed by significance rather than number, so one substantial merit may outweigh many sins, and outward observation is insufficient to judge a person.
The source brings differing opinions.
Quote from the source«מדידת המצוות והעבירות נעשות באיכותן ולא בכמותן.»
- Author
- הרמב"ם; הראב"ד; כסף משנה
- Source
- Other — נעם זיוך-פרשת כי תבוא-חינוך בחיוך, p. 4
- Parsha
- Ki Tavo