May one recite Kaddish and study Torah in a cemetery for the merit of the deceased?
Tosafot and Ramban explain the account of Torah study at Hezekiah’s grave as referring to students sitting four cubits away; Ramban also requires moving away from the cemetery to recite Kaddish. Nimukei Yosef and Ri Migash permit study in honor of the deceased because it expresses respect rather than mockery. The Shulchan Aruch accepts this permission, and Rav Ovadia notes that the overwhelming majority of later authorities agree and that this is the established custom. Netziv also permits prayers and blessings unrelated to the deceased’s needs, since a grave ten handbreadths deep constitutes a separate domain. The publication nevertheless states that customary practice permits Kaddish for the deceased and Torah study in their merit, without adopting this broader permission.
A practical halachic question: the final ruling is for your rabbi.
The source brings differing opinions.
Quote from the source«לעומת זאת אם לימוד התורה נעשה שלא לצורך המת, אז אכן אסור ללמוד בבית הקברות.»
- Author
- התוספות; הרמב''ן; הנימוקי יוסף; הר''י מיגאש; השולחן ערוך; הרב עובדיה; הנצי''ב; Редакция «הלכה בפרשה»
- Source
- הלכה בפרשה — הלכה בפרשה — Chayei Sarah 5787, p. 2
- Parsha
- Chayei Sarah