Whose judgment is followed when a patient and doctors disagree about eating on Yom Kippur?
If the patient says food is needed, the patient is fed despite one doctor's disagreement; Mar bar Rav Ashi accepts the patient's statement even against a hundred doctors. If a doctor says food is necessary and the patient denies it, the patient is also fed because illness may impair judgment. When two doctors identify a danger, food is given despite opposing assessments, since doubt concerning life is resolved in favor of saving it.
A practical halachic question: the final ruling is for your rabbi.
The source brings differing opinions.
Quote from the source«אבל בפיקוח נפש אפי' בספק מותר»
- Author
- מר בר רב אשי; Редакция «תמצית הש"ס גמרא רש"י»
- Source
- תמצית הש"ס גמרא רש"י — תמצית הש"ס גמרא רש"י — Vayeira 5787, p. 2
- Parsha
- Vayera