Why is an animal of doubtful tithe status exempt from the priestly gifts?
Even Rabbi Meir, who requires the gifts in the doubtful-firstborn case discussed, exempts an animal of doubtful tithe status. In that firstborn case, the kohen is entitled either to the animal itself or to its gifts, whereas that reasoning does not apply to doubtful animal tithe. The firstborn ruling is therefore not a general enactment intended to keep the obligation of priestly gifts from being forgotten.
A practical halachic question: the final ruling is for your rabbi.
Quote from the source«ספק מעשר פטור במתנות אף לר"מ שמחייב לעיל בספק בכור»
- Author
- רבי מאיר
- Source
- תמצית הש"ס גפ"ת — תמצית הש"ס גפ"ת — Vayeira 5787, p. 3
- Parsha
- Vayera