Will a declaration before witnesses preserve my right to recover an overcharge that I knowingly pay?
The Bach holds that a buyer can preserve a claim for repayment by informing two witnesses of his intention before purchasing. The Ketsos objects that such a declaration can undo a purchase only under duress, while the Nesivos accepts its effectiveness for recovering an overcharge of exactly one sixth without cancelling the sale. For the furniture purchase described, with a known overcharge of roughly twenty-five percent, Rabbi Fleischman concludes that the declaration will not help because the prevailing view rejects the Bach's position.
A practical halachic question: the final ruling is for your rabbi.
The source brings differing opinions.
This answer was given to a specific person, not as a general rule.
Quote from the source«The Nesivos (227, 4) partially disagrees with the Ketsos.»
- Author
- Rabbi Yosef Fleischman
- Source
- Torah & Horaah — Torah & Horaah — rabbi fleischman-matos-masei - knowingly purchased furniture at an inflated price — Matos-Massei 5786, p. 2
- Parsha
- Matot