What would have happened to the lands of Sichon and Og if Gad and Reuven had not requested them?
Rabbi Chaim Shaul Kaufman presents several explanations: Ramban says the lands would have remained uninhabited, while Pnei Yehoshua considers the conquest Moshe's royal possession, which he generously gave to Israel. Haamek Davar and the cited explanation of the Griz envisage shares beyond the Jordan for the entire people, including the priests. Sfat Emet holds that these lands were already intended for Gad and Reuven, but only after the conquest and division of the land.
The source brings differing opinions.
Quote from the source«והביא דיש בזה כמה וכמה מהלכים בספרי המפרשים.»
- Author
- רבי חיים שאול קויפמאן
- Source
- מדשן ביתך — מדשן ביתך — Matos-Massei 5786, p. 30
- Parsha
- Matot