Why is a nazir’s abstinence sometimes called holy and sometimes sinful?
The Alshich explains that earthly pleasures were created to sustain the living soul, so unnecessary self-denial is sinful. Abstinence for the sake of Heaven, such as for atonement, can nevertheless be accepted like an offering. In his interpretation, completing the nazirite term without impurity shows that this service was accepted, whereas unexpected corpse impurity shows that it was not fully accepted. Such a nazir therefore needs atonement for depriving himself of wine.
Quote from the source«So, if he fasts or causes himself unnecessary suffering, he is considered a sinner.»
- Author
- Alshich
- Source
- Shvilei Pinchas — Shvilei Pinchas — nasso-5786--rav pincha friedman - english — Naso 5786, p. 5
- Parsha
- Naso