When permitted food absorbs a forbidden taste, is subsequent nullification measured against the whole piece or only the absorbed prohibition?
Rabbeinu Tam holds that a piece prohibited by an absorbed taste becomes an independent forbidden entity, known as chatichah na’asit neveilah. Nullification in sixty therefore requires measuring against the entire piece. Rabbeinu Ephraim holds that, for prohibitions other than meat with milk, the food carrying the forbidden taste does not become independently forbidden, so only the absorbed prohibition is measured. The text does not provide a final practical ruling on this dispute.
The source brings differing opinions.
Quote from the source«חלקו רבינו תם ורבינו אפרים איך להתייחס לחתיכה מותרת שקבלה טעם של איסור.»
- Author
- רבינו תם; רבינו אפרים
- Source
- חמדת ימים — חמדת ימים — Emor 5786, p. 2
- Parsha
- Emor