Why was the source and recitation of Tefillah Zakah disputed?
Chaiye Adam popularized the prayer, and R. Danzig identified the controversial Hemdat Yamim as its source; some editions removed that attribution. R. Meshulum Finkelstein defended the prayer by arguing that its text differs from the source and that restrictions on later prayers apply to exceptional individuals rather than everyone; popular acceptance is also cited as a defense. The article’s author objects that Danzig explicitly named the source and that substantial passages do derive from it.
The source brings differing opinions.
Quote from the source«The source to popularize this prayer is the book Chaiye Adam.»
- Author
- R. Meshulum Finkelstein; Редакция «Parsha Pages»
- Source
- Parsha Pages — parsha pages yom kippur — Sukkos 5787, p. 18