I am not Jewish, my husband is. Can our son have a brit milah, and then grow up and convert?
Circumcision must not be done, because the child is not Jewish. If it is done, in time he will be sure he is Jewish, and in adolescence he may suffer a severe psychological trauma. The claim "he'll grow up and convert" is thoughtless: conversion is voluntary, and one cannot predict whether he will want it and agree to lead a full Jewish life. Statistics show the opposite: people whose only Jewish parent is the father are often resentful of Jewish law and see conversion merely as "restoring justice," ready to resort to tricks to obtain the needed "paper"; the media push the idea that anyone entitled to immigrate to Israel may consider himself a Jew and stir up hatred toward our teachers. All this can be avoided by living "truthfully": the child must know he is not Jewish, and when he grows up he will decide for himself how to live; only a genuine, sincere conversion can be considered. On attending synagogue the rabbi gives no specific answer, but he firmly recommends that the husband study Torah — find a group, attend classes at synagogues, use the website.
A practical halachic question: the final ruling is for your rabbi.
This answer was given to a specific person, not as a general rule.
Quote from the source«Ваш ребенок должен знать, что он — нееврей.»
- Author
- Элиягу Эссас
- Source
- Love Doing Good — journal-187, p. 9