Is Neilah a separate Amidah or only a special confession?
Rav regards Neilah as an additional Amidah, while Shmuel understands it as the recitation of Ma Anu, Meh Chayeinu. The Gemara rejects Shmuel's opinion based on a Beraisa whose two positions both assume an additional Amidah. R. Yosef D. Soloveitchik explains the underlying dispute as whether Neilah is an obligation of prayer or of confession.
The source brings differing opinions.
Quote from the source«According to Rav, it is an additional Amidah.»
- Author
- Rabbi Joshua Flug
- Source
- Parsha Pages — Parsha Pages — a machzor compendium — Sukkos 5787, p. 34