How does Amalek differ from Esau, and may a modern nation be called Amalek?
Amalek descends from Esau, but the two are not identical. In David Elman's explanation, Esau represents a broader historical opposition to Jacob, while Amalek is its extreme expression: seeking to undermine Israel's confidence in its purpose even without any rational benefit. Their family connection does not mean that every expression of Esau is Amalek or that one may independently declare any modern nation to be Amalek.
This answer was given to a specific person, not as a general rule.
Quote from the source«Амалек и Эсав — не одно и то же, хотя между ними есть прямая связь.»
- Author
- Давид Эльман
- Source
- Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№595 Специальный выпуск к Рош аШана, p. 10