Can a sacrificial vow be fulfilled by bringing an animal worth more or less than the one promised?
Someone who promised a bull but brought a calf has not fulfilled the vow. In the reverse case, Rabbi considers the vow unfulfilled, while the Sages consider it fulfilled; the halacha follows the Sages. The explanation is that the more valuable offering fulfills the substance of the promise and even exceeds it. Reducing the gift, however, also diminishes the attachment to God that it expresses.
A practical halachic question: the final ruling is for your rabbi.
The source brings differing opinions.
Quote from the source«Il en résulte que celui qui s’engage à offrir un veau peut offrir un bœuf, dont la valeur est supérieure.»
- Author
- Rabbi de Loubavitch
- Source
- Likouteï Si’hot — Likouteï Si’hot — likout vaykra — Vayikra 5786, p. 5
- Parsha
- Vayikra