Why does Rabbi require five judges in monetary cases?
Rabbi reads the phrase asher yarshiun elohim as indicating two judges and correspondingly understands the preceding elohim as another two. A fifth is added so that the court has an odd number of members. The text rejects the explanation that five are needed merely so that three can form a majority at the verdict.
The source brings differing opinions.
Quote from the source«וכיון שאין בי"ד שקול הרי כאן חמשה»
- Author
- רבי
- Source
- תמצית חבורת ש"ס — תמצית חבורת ש"ס — sukkos tamtzis chaburas shas lashon kodesh 5787, p. 2