Why does Shmuel distinguish between a canopy and a house as bodily covering for reciting Shema?
According to Shmuel, an unclothed person inside a canopy lower than ten handbreadths may extend their head outside and recite Shema, because the canopy is treated like clothing rather than a separate enclosure. At ten handbreadths it is a tent, so extending the head is insufficient. In a house this does not help even at a lower height because it is permanent; Tosafot also note that Shmuel's stated position does not take account of the issue of the heart being uncovered toward the nakedness.
A practical halachic question: the final ruling is for your rabbi.
Quote from the source«ואמנם בבית אפי' פחות מי' לא מהני שיוציא ראשו כיון דקביע.»
- Author
- שמואל
- Source
- אוסף הדרכות והנהגות — אוסף הדרכות והנהגות — sukkos oisef hadruchos vehanhugos lashon kodesh 5787, p. 15