Why did the Rebbe remind the rabbis that they could have agreed earlier to Mashiach’s immediate arrival?
According to the story, after Yom Kippur the Rebbe asked the rabbis present to issue a ruling so that, with Mashiach’s arrival, Jews outside the Land of Israel would celebrate Sukkot together with its residents, for just one festival day. One rabbi began discussing whether the second festival day would be abolished and declined to rule; when he expressed everyone’s agreement on Sukkot that Mashiach should come immediately, the Rebbe reminded him of the earlier opportunity. An editorial note also cites later statements by the Rebbe allowing for the possibility that the second festival day would remain in the future, so the story does not establish a definitive ruling on that issue.
The source brings differing opinions.
Quote from the source«הרי הייתה לכם הברירה במוצאי יום כיפור?!»
- Author
- הרבי
- Source
- Nosei Shavui — תורת הרבי — תשכ''א 2, p. 5