Must an esrog that is kosher only according to some opinions be replaced?
The Biur Halachah distinguishes improving appearance from obtaining an item whose validity is undisputed. Even when one may rely on the permissive opinions, one must exchange the esrog for an unquestionably kosher one if this is possible for an additional third of the cost.
A practical halachic question: the final ruling is for your rabbi.
Quote from the source«If the first purchase was only kosher according to some opinions, although one can rely on them halachically, if it is possible to exchange it for something kosher without doubt at an added 1/3 of the cost, one must do so.»
- Author
- Biur Halachah
- Source
- למודי משה — למודי משה — succos a5 5784, p. 37