Should one prefer an intact esrog even after the first day of Succos?
Although chosar itself does not disqualify after the first day, several authorities cite the view that an incomplete mitzvah item should ideally be avoided throughout Succos for hiddur mitzvah. The article illustrates this with the Chazon Ish's instruction to replace an esrog whose uketz had fallen off during Chol HaMoed. This concerns the preferred manner of fulfillment, rather than extending the basic disqualification of chosar to every day.
A practical halachic question: the final ruling is for your rabbi.
Quote from the source«A number of poskim (Shu”t Toras Chesed, Orach Chaim 36 and Mikraei Kodesh 2:26) bring from Rishonim (Tomim De’im of the Ra’avad, siman 233 and Meiri, Succah 36b) that lechatchilah [ideally] one should refrain from using something which is chasor the entire Succos, due to the din of זה אלי ואנוהו, the din of hiddur mitzvah.»
- Author
- R’ Yom Tov Sanger
- Source
- למודי משה — למודי משה — succos a5 5784, p. 27